Nonnas Pizza Reviews, Ratings & Menu | 131 Center St, Southington, CT

General Info

Located at 131 Center St, Southington, CT 06489, Nonnas Pizza is a pizza restaurant that offers a welcoming atmosphere and a menu packed with comforting favorites. From the moment you step inside, the focus on classic pizza-making and satisfying flavors is easy to notice. Whether you're stopping by for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or ordering food to enjoy at home, this local spot provides a convenient and enjoyable dining experience.

One of the standout items on the menu is the White Margherita, a pizza that highlights simple ingredients and balanced flavors. Guests looking for a more indulgent option often gravitate toward the Small Extra Cheese Pizza, which delivers the rich, cheesy taste many pizza lovers crave. Another memorable choice is the Penne Ala Vodka Pizza, combining the familiar appeal of pizza with the creamy character of a beloved pasta-inspired sauce. These specialty selections help give the menu variety while staying true to the restaurant’s identity.

Beyond pizza, Nonnas Pizza also features unique offerings such as Zwiebelkuchen, providing diners with an opportunity to enjoy something a little different alongside traditional favorites. The restaurant’s signature sauce plays an important role across several menu items, adding depth and consistency to the overall dining experience.

During my visit, I appreciated the relaxed setting and attentive table service. The staff maintained a friendly and professional approach, helping create a comfortable environment for both regular customers and first-time visitors. For those who prefer to enjoy their meal elsewhere, no-contact delivery is available, making it easy to order with convenience in mind.

Practical amenities also contribute to a smooth experience. Nonnas Pizza accepts credit cards, allowing for hassle-free payment whether dining in or placing an order for delivery. Guests should note that there is no wheelchair accessible restroom available at the location. Even so, the restaurant continues to attract customers seeking quality pizza, dependable service, and a satisfying meal.

When browsing reviews of pizza restaurants in Southington, Nonnas Pizza stands out for its combination of flavorful menu options, reliable service, and convenient location. Its selection of specialty pizzas, signature sauce, and unique dishes creates an experience that keeps diners returning to explore more of the menu while enjoying one of the area's familiar local dining locations.

What customers say?

“ Their pizza is fantastic. Got a cheese to go at the end of the night. Always wanted to try it. Will be back!!!! Fantastic place, great guy! One of the best I've had outside New Haven. ”

- andrew tita -

“ Nonna’s Pizzeria used to host a pizza challenge where a team of two would be given 20 minutes to devour an entire 30-inch pie to win. Only one singular team ever completed it in the requisite time making it seem impossible, until one fateful day when Shawn (aka Basketlockerball) stepped through Nonna’s doors… He strolled in and effortlessly inhaled the entire 30 inch pizza in a mere 12:30! The owner thoroughly flabbergasted by this feat retired the challenge after that day. Sad to see a relatively close challenge get retired, I reached out to Ace Nonna to see if he could revive his pizza challenge so I could give it a shot. He originally said he would bring it back ONLY if I could be Shawn’s record (which felt ludicrous), but then he had an even wilder idea! He set up an entire day’s worth of Pizza eating contests instead! He blocked off the entire street and called in the news team for the occasion. The day began with an amateurs round where competitors competed to see who could eat an 18 inch pizza the fastest. The next round was a head to head match up between Southington’s fire department and police department to see who could eat the 30 in pizza as a team the fastest. The whole day ended with one final head to head between me and Shawn as we each ate one of Nonna’s 30 inch pizza solo. Shawn absolutely DEMOLISHED his previous record by eating the pizza in 9:32. I tried my hardest to clear the pizza in Shawn’s old time of 12:30, but ended up finishing it in 14:48. Slightly bummed I couldn’t snag a record time, I am happy with my performance being under 15 minutes which still landed me way faster than any of the teams that attempted the challenge while Ace still offered it at his restaurant. I was lucky to have such supportive home state crowd support! The last 5 minutes of my eating felt so laborious, but the crowd never stopped believing in me and cheered me on to the very last bite. The pizza here hit all the marks. Perfect balance of gooey cheese, vibrantly seasoned sauce, and a well done crispy crust. Even after eating almost 6 pounds of Nonna’s pizza, it never got any less delicious (just hard to chew after 14 mins of non stop eating). Huge thank you to Ace for working all day to make such incredible pizza and for reviving this delicious pizza challenge. I don’t know how he had the energy to prepare so many pies while also having the energy to get on the mic and keep the crowd riled up during each round. He’s as much a pizza craftsman as he is a showman.I hope he keep this a yearly tradition! I will defiantly have to come back for more pizza and beat my old time! ”

- Jerome Burns -

“ One of the best pizzas I've ever tasted. The dough was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, the cheese melted perfectly and the ingredients super fresh. You can tell that they make it with love and quality. I will definitely be back — 100% recommended! ”

- Junior Galvan -